TrustWatt
    Back to browse

    Tesla Model Y vs Hyundai Ioniq 5 – Owner Reviews Compared

    Rating Comparison

    Tesla Model YHyundai Ioniq 5
    8.9
    Overall
    9.0
    8.6
    Reliability
    8.6
    8.1
    Comfort
    8.5
    8.2
    Range
    8.2
    8.3
    Charging
    8.5
    9.1
    Performance
    8.1
    8.4
    Value
    8.4

    Spec Comparison

    Tesla Model YHyundai Ioniq 5
    Price from£41,990£43,445
    Range (WLTP)283 miles240 miles
    Real-world range171 miles180 miles
    Battery60 kWh58 kWh
    0–62 mph6.9s8.5s
    Top speed217 mph185 mph
    Boot854 litres527 litres
    Seats55
    AC charge time495 min316 min
    DC charge time28 min18 min

    What Owners Say

    Tesla Model Y

    What owners love

    Space for everything. Two car seats, dog crate in the boot, still room.

    Practical and the app is great.

    Supercharger network makes the trips to Inverness easy.

    What to watch out for

    Road noise on the motorway is louder than I expected for the money.

    Build quality has a few rough edges. One trim panel rattles.

    Suspension is hard on the farm track.

    Hyundai Ioniq 5

    What owners love

    Charges stupidly fast when you find a decent rapid. 10 to 80 in about 20 mins at Ionity.

    All wheel drive on a wet single track in February is worth every penny.

    Faster charging than anything else I've tried. Brilliant for the Highlands.

    What to watch out for

    Nearest reliable rapid is 25 miles away. Fine with home charging but plan the long ones.

    Cold mornings knock a chunk off the range and the rapid network up here is thin. One broken unit at Aviemore and you are re-planning the whole day.

    Wing mirrors are small and it is wide for a village car park.

    The Verdict

    Based on 85 owner reviews, the Hyundai Ioniq 5 scores higher overall at 9.0/10 compared to the Tesla Model Y at 8.9/10. Hyundai Ioniq 5 owners rate it particularly well for reliability, while the Tesla Model Y stands out for performance.

    Other Popular Comparisons

    Own one of these cars?

    Add your review to help others compare

    Share your review